| Custom-Produced accompaniment tracks allow the artist to choose his or
her own precise key, tempos and general style. Some artists even provide some input
in terms of the arrangement "concept" and sometimes suggested instruments; for
the most part, though, the arranging is left to the arranger. There are two basic
approaches to recording custom tracks: 1) Live musicians, and 2) MIDI which uses
'digitally' generated sounds, which are typically 'sequenced' on a computer. One's first
reaction is that "live" musicians are preferred over "MIDI" sounds.
But hold on. Eagles Nest took several years generating an arsenal of extremely
realistic orchestral sounds. Celebrated arranger, Ralph Carmichael, called them
"the most convincing sounds he's ever heard." In fact, we subjected our
orchestrations to the scrutiny of 25 musicians and found most of them could not tell the
difference.
While MIDI can save thousands of dollars, especially using full orchestra with large
string sections, many tracks call for live musicians ... or a combination of live and
MIDI. The subtleties of guitar, in particular, are often difficult to sequence using
MIDI. The choice between live and MIDI is typically dictated by 1) Style of
music, and 2) Size of Orchestra.
Guidelines based on 'style' of music
- Country / Southern Gospel - LIVE
Rhythm section. If "Sweetening" is desired (strings, oboe, etc.) at Eagles
Nest we typically sweeten using MIDI sounds because they sound so authentic.
- Contemporary - LIVE Rhythm
section. If desired, add "Sweetening" afterwards using MIDI.
- Classical / Symphonic - MIDI
sounds may be used exclusively.
- Big Band / Jazz - MIDI
sounds. Depending on how "exposed" the drums appear, it may be desirable
to play 'live' drums in place of the MIDI drums. If there are 'solo' sections for trumpet,
sax, etc., it may be desirable to rerecord some solo lines using LIVE player(s).
- Blues / Black Gospel - LIVE
Rhythm section. Add LIVE solo instruments (sax, etc.). Use MIDI strings if
desired.
- Inspirational (orchestral) - Use
MIDI sounds. Typically because of the amount of orchestration, MIDI drums and bass
will usually work very well. If there are very stylized or exposed guitar solos, a
live guitar may be recorded after the track is finished.
- Rock - LIVE Rhythm
section almost always.
|
|